Mitigating Slip-and-Fall Claims: Best Practices for Snow Removal & Liability (2026)
For residential property managers, winter isn't just about snow—it’s about liability. A single slip-and-fall claim on an icy walkway can lead to massive lawsuits, increased insurance premiums, or even bankruptcy.
Meticulous documentation and proactive risk management are your only defenses against allegations of negligence. By maintaining detailed snow removal logs and enforcing strict protocols, property managers can establish a "paper trail" that proves due diligence.
In this guide, we explore the essential strategies to mitigate slip-and-fall risks, from vetting contractors to leveraging your insurance broker.
1. The Power of Documentation: Logs & Visual Evidence
The importance of documenting snow removal efforts cannot be overstated. If you are dragged into court, your memory won't save you—your logs will.
- Written Logs: Maintain detailed logs recording the exact date, time, and specific areas (walkways, parking lots) where snow and ice removal took place.
- Visual Proof: Use time-stamped images and video footage of cleared common areas. This visual evidence validates that you took reasonable measures to mitigate hazardous conditions.
Why this matters: A comprehensive paper trail serves as a deterrent against frivolous claims and strengthens your position during negotiations with insurance adjusters.
2. Selecting & Vetting a Reputable Snow Contractor
Your liability often depends on who you hire. Vetting snow removal vendors thoroughly is crucial. Look for companies with a proven track record in servicing residential communities.
Key Contractual Protections:
- Insurance Verification: Ensure they carry Snow Removal Insurance including General Liability and Workers' Compensation.
- Indemnity Clauses: These provisions transfer liability from you (the property owner) to the contractor in the event of their negligence.
- Accountability: Implement a reporting system for missed areas. Regular inspections ensure the contractor is meeting the agreed-upon standards.
3. Reducing Financial Impact: Deductibles & Broker Advocacy
One significant challenge for property managers is the accumulation of out-of-pocket expenses from high insurance deductibles. Small claims often fall below the deductible threshold, forcing the property management company to pay the bill.
Strategies to Manage Costs:
- Analyze Your Deductible: Work with an experienced insurance broker to conduct a cost-benefit analysis. sometimes, a slightly higher premium is worth it to lower your deductible for frequent small claims.
- The Broker’s Role: A dedicated broker acts as a mediator. Unlike a claims adjuster who protects the insurer, your broker advocates for your interest, challenging unfair denials and ensuring swift resolutions.
> Note: This is why many REITs and Property Managers choose Summit Commercial Solutions—we provide value beyond just the policy.
4. Implementing a Tenant Insurance Program
Enforcing tenant insurance requirements in large communities is an ongoing headache. However, gaps in coverage can expose property owners to risk.
The Solution: A Master PolicyConsider a "Blanket Policy" program where all tenants are automatically covered.
- Streamlined Claims: Eliminates the need to track individual tenant renewals.
- Coverage Certainty: Ensures that if a tenant causes damage (e.g., leaving a window open during a storm), there is coverage in place to pay for it.
5. Managing Liability from Non-Tenants (Public Safety)
Liability extends beyond your tenants. Sidewalks and parking lots are open to visitors, delivery drivers, and passersby.
To defend against third-party claims:
- Clear Timelines: Establish policies stating that walkways must be cleared within 12 hours of snowfall (or as per local bylaws).
- Surveillance: Cameras are vital. Footage can prove the claimant was distracted (e.g., looking at their phone) or that the area was recently cleared.
- Eyewitness Accounts: Gather statements from staff or bystanders immediately after an incident while memories are fresh.
6. Conducting Regular Property Inspections
Proactive identification of hazards is better than reactive defense.Regular inspections should assess:
- Uneven surfaces or cracks in walkways that could be hidden by snow.
- Poor drainage areas where ice creates "black ice" hazards.
- Lighting in parking lots (poor visibility increases slip risks).
Winter Specifics: Consider installing heated walkways or using specific de-icing agents for high-traffic zones to prevent refreezing.
Case Study: The $3 Million Lesson
The Incident:In 2019, a tenant at a Rockville Condominium suffered severe injuries on an icy pathway. The property managers had hired a snow removal company but failed to inspect the site after the storm.
The Consequence:The tenant sued for $3 Million. The investigation revealed the contract lacked clear "de-icing" language, and the property manager had zero documentation of snow removal efforts.
The Takeaway:
- Contracts must be specific.
- Inspections are mandatory.
- No logs = No defense.
Final Thoughts: Partner for Protection
By analyzing past liability events and implementing robust documentation protocols, property managers can prevent history from repeating itself.
A proactive approach to liability is key to safeguarding your residents and your assets. Don't wait for the lawsuit to find out your coverage is lacking.
Reach out to Summit today to better manage your risk.
👉 Get a Commercial Insurance Quote
